Transcript:
SG: Dr. Sajjan Gohel
KG: Dr. Karie Gibson
SG: Welcome to the NATO DEEP Dive Podcast. I’m your host, Dr. Sajjan M. Gohel, and in this episode, I speak with Dr. Karie Gibson.
For more than two decades, Dr. Karie Gibson has helped law enforcement and organisations see risk early, act with clarity, and protect the people and operations that matter most. She is a licensed psychologist, certified FBI profiler, and most recently, unit chief of the FBI’s Behavioural Analysis Unit. After retiring from the FBI, she now is the CEO of Twin Oaks Consulting and an adjunct faculty member at the University of Virginia.
Dr. Karie Gibson, warm welcome to NATO DEEP Dive.
KG: Good morning. Thank you for having me.
SG: It’s our pleasure. You came into the FBI as a psychologist and later led one of its behavioural analysis units, these are world famous. What can an offender’s behaviour reveal that conventional investigative evidence cannot? And where must a profiler be careful not to mistake an interpretation for effect?
KG: Great question. I feel personally that the offender’s behaviour can tell you a lot about the investigation that needs to go forward, as well as specific reasons for certain dynamics that you might see in that investigation. If you think about it, we’re not necessarily, as law enforcement officers, not necessarily in tune to focus on behaviour. We’re meant to focus on actual criminal acts that have occurred, and does that meet the threshold for some type of chargeable offence. And so, there’s many times that something will happen, and we just kind of chalk it up to, well, ‘I don’t know why that was’, and we kind of move on as law enforcement officers.
I think that looking at behavioural analysis and what I learned as being a profiler in the FBI, is there’s a lot of layers to human behaviour, and there’s a lot that we can know about the offender based off of their behaviour and their actions if we take time to kind of understand that and look for patterns and trends that are present that we see over time. I feel like when you’re looking at that, it does take a little bit of time and attention to really kind of unpack that and ask those questions, versus just assuming you know based off of your life. Again, you have to be diversified in what that behaviour could mean, but I have found that it’s very telling and it helps us if we can understand the behaviour that will help us unlock certain doors as we go forward in the investigation that down the road will be very important.
You’re always hoping to get in front of that offender who’s committed that crime and have that conversation, and if you have already put time into understanding a little bit of how they could be thinking or feeling based on their behaviour, you already will be ahead of the game in that interaction with them and hopefully be able to use that to your benefit.
I think, to your second part of the question: ‘what is a mistake that could happen or what must profilers be careful not to do.’ I think that again it all comes down to the behaviour and you need to have the offenders interacting in a way that there is behaviour. So, sometimes there may not be much actual behaviour that you can see. For example, let’s say a drive-by shooting. What behaviour of the offender do you have? Not very much. Someone driving by, pulling a firearm out of the vehicle, and shooting at somebody. That’s a drive-by shooting. So, the behaviour is pretty minimal in that example, versus somebody committing a homicide and they spend hours with the body, they spend hours in the victim’s house, they are doing different things at that moment in time that really will help inform their behaviour.
So, what happens I think, is that when you’re in this place, you’re looking for that behaviour and it can be really informative when you find it and when it’s there, but there is I think a tendency to want to opine on behaviour that’s not there. To assume or use your gut to inform next steps or practises and that’s just a high-risk endeavour, it’s really no better than flipping a coin. But I have seen there is a little bit of a pull for that when you’re a subject matter expert and you’ve been trained in behavioural analysis; you want to be able to comment and inform people on the questions that they ask. But with that, you have to be, as a true subject matter expert, you have to be able to recognise when you don’t have expertise and help them understand what they don’t have. And if I don’t have a behavioural-rich environment or a behavioural-rich set of facts and circumstances, there’s not much that I can do with behavioural analysis.
SG: That’s very interesting. To build on that, you worked on many grisly investigations of serial killers, including the case of Steven Zelich and the murders of Laura Simonson and Jenny Gamez. Could you take us through a moment when understanding his behaviour materially changed the investigation or the approach to interviewing him? What lesson from the case has stayed with you? And maybe just perhaps for those that aren’t aware of the case, just briefly talk about what he did.
KG: Absolutely. So, Steven Zelich was a former police officer that had been fired for misuse of his position and really inappropriate behaviour of targeting females in his community. Ultimately, he goes on to prey upon vulnerable women on a BDSM webpage called CollerMe.com. And so, he sets up and becomes a person who wants to be a dominant person in that environment and looks for a permanent slave or a submissive person to be a part of his BDSM fantasies and lifestyle. He encounters both Jenny Gamez and Laura Simonson on that platform and ultimately convinces them, first Jenny and then Laura, but starts with Jenny, and convinces them to become his permanent slave and travel across the United States to come live with him in that permanent slave status.
As Jenny travels, she ultimately arrives at the airport, he picks her up and then ultimately ends up killing her on the second day she was there in Wisconsin. Ultimately, in that situation, most people would get rid of the body, get rid of the evidence, but he does something that’s kind of unique and I think very specific to how he saw them. He keeps Jenny, he transports her back to his residence, he cleans out his refrigerator, he puts her in the refrigerator, and he keeps her there for about 15 months. And he did that because that was really seen as his prized possession. He very much took possession of her.
As time went on, he met Laura. He did the same thing with Laura, trying to convince her to come to Wisconsin to be his permanent slave. He has success in that. He drives to pick her up in Minnesota. They stay at a motel before he goes back to Wisconsin and does the same thing kills Laura right before checkout, just like he had done with Jenny.
He killed both these women in an act called breath play, which is a BDSM, high-end kind of edge play, they will call it. A performative action that they do where ultimately, it is about restricting someone’s breathing and choking them. And in this situation for both of them, he ended up killing them in that way. Time went on when he brought Laura back to his residence again, just like Jenny, that was seen as his prized possession, but he only had one refrigerator. And so now he had two bodies and what was he going to do?
Well, for him, it was November in Wisconsin. It was cold. So, he was able to keep Laura in the trunk of his vehicle. He ultimately thought, well, this works perfectly. Let me get Jenny out of the refrigerator and move her to the trunk of my vehicle. So, at that time he did that and he kept both Laura and Jenny in the trunk of his vehicle from November until June when he ultimately had to dispose of them because of the significant weather change. It was warm in Wisconsin in June and there started to be a real odour emanating from his vehicle.
And so, he ultimately discarded them on the side of the road in their actual suitcases that they had travelled with, with their belongings. And then it was through DNA that they connected him to their homicides and then he was prosecuted and convicted.
So, that is the case. So, specifically in looking at that related to your questions that you asked about it, I think for that case, there was the initial kind of just trying to understand what was happening. There’s a lot of moving parts. First, it was Laura really, where we came to understand her being missing and the connection to Steven Zelich and wanting to try to figure out where she was and recover her. As time went on, it became very clear that something bad had happened to Laura. So, we’re really focused on that part of the investigation. It wasn’t until we found Laura discarded on the side of the road that we understood the significance of what had happened because then Jenny was found as well. And at that time, we didn’t know who Jenny was. She was Jane Doe. No one had reported Jenny missing.
And so, when you’re looking at that case and you’re trying to focus on the key factors that could hold that offender accountable, right? You’re trying to build the case. You’re trying to get the evidence. That’s one aspect of it. The other aspect from my standing was really trying to understand how did we get here? There was an odd case. There was offender behaviour that was interesting, that he did. And that had to have significance and had to be able to be utilised in a way that could be productive in ultimately getting justice for Jenny and Laura. And so, when we were in that investigative point of arresting him and interviewing him, I would say really where the key factor came in, that really, I felt kind of changed him and his behaviour and really kind of changed the conversation with him.
Initially, the interview was happening by the detectives, and they were going through everything that he was talking about, again, related to BDSM, related to the sexual component of his behaviour and he was very much being standoffish. He was very much not at all admitting or even having a conversation about some of those more, I would say, personal factors for him that were related to the why behind his behaviour. And he could easily tell that the detectives had not before been involved in that type of discussion or behaviour, that it was new for them, that they felt uncomfortable. I think he could tell that they felt uncomfortable in those discussions, and he was just blowing them off.
And so, we reconvened as a team and talked through different aspects of what we could do to try to get an upper hand in that conversation and really start to elicit some type of dynamic that would allow key information to be shared by Steven Zelich. I had a background as a clinical psychologist and a forensic psychologist before I came into the Bureau. Part of that experience that I had prior to the Bureau was I worked with civilly committed sex offenders in the state of Minnesota and the state of Washington. And so, I have had a lot of time in conversations with sex offenders about disordered arousal and different dynamics there. And so, we started talking about, well, what would it be like if we went in and presented myself as Dr. Karie Gibson, which I am, and talked through those more unique aspects to his behaviour? And we did that.
And ultimately, in that moment, we saw a change in his behaviour. We saw him respond to that. He felt special. He felt, again, we were kind of, you know, in that moment really trying to have him feel special and have him really kind of lower his defensiveness and to start to share. And so, I enter into that conversation as Dr. Karie Gibson with the FBI and really wanting to help understand how we got here and hear, you know, his specific story connected to that. And then with that, I had the expertise related to the disordered arousal. So, I had the ability to challenge him on some of the minimisation that he was doing in his discussions. He saw that right away and he actually, you could tell he respected that. And so, in that moment, it really forged, I think, for him two things.
One, he felt special. He wanted to share with me because he could feel, I think, feel significance in a way that he hadn’t felt in a long time. He felt connected to the law enforcement arm. He felt legitimised in that process. And so ultimately, he started to share. Now, we never got him to admit fully that he, you know, orchestrated Jenny coming with the intent to kill her, orchestrated Laura coming to, you know, to be his permanent slave to kill her. But what we did get is we did get him to admit that breath play is dangerous, that it’s deadly, and that he knew the risks of that before he decided to do that with Jenny.
He realised that he went too far with Jenny and that he killed her and he decided to cover that up versus offer aid, call 911, do anything to explain the accidental nature that he was claiming, which he understood and shared that that wasn’t the best choice he could have made in that moment. And then we got him to talk about how on his way to meet Laura, he thought about Jenny. He thought about how he killed Jenny during breath play. He thought about what that made him feel. And he decided that he was going to do breath play with Laura, even though it had proved to be deadly with Jenny.
And so, from our aspect, it seemed very clear that this was, for him, not an accident. If you go back to the structure of BDSM and the lifestyle being about dominance and control, for him, he wanted to be the dominant one, he wanted to have the ultimate control. And through taking their lives, ultimately, that is the control that he had and that he was able to really enact. And so, I feel in that moment, that made the difference to be able to connect with him on that level, to make him feel like he wasn’t a freak, like he wasn’t at all this person that nobody could connect with.
When I came in with my expertise, ultimately, for him, it served in his mind, likely as a validation of who he was, and that he felt special. And then with that, he shared a lot of information that was specifically about that. And you could really start to see for him; he was a predator. He was a psychopath. It’s all about him and his needs. And they were just pawns in that and they were his property.
SG: Very, very chilling case. And very interesting insight as to his mindset as well. When you compare serial killers like that with people involved in violent online networks, how much overlap do you see in their pursuit of control, gratification, and recognition? Does having an online audience change the behaviour itself, rather than simply give the offender somewhere to display it?
KG: No, it’s a great point. My personal view on it is that it’s very similar behaviour that’s happening online that we see that happens in real life with predatory offenders. And so,if we recognise these key elements, these foundational elements that are at the core of predatory behaviour and exploitation of victims and what the offender gets out of that behaviour, it can be facilitated very easily online. And it’s really that, from my view of it, the same type of crime that we’re seeing, but it’s just being orchestrated online.
I think what makes it different is it’s harder to get in front of, it’s harder to stop. There’s so many opportunities online for somebody who wants to prey on somebody who’s vulnerable. And so, when we are looking at that online behaviour and we’re trying to understand it, again, it looks different. But if we really go through the layers of that and get to the foundational element, you have predators that are seeking out vulnerable individuals online and exploiting them and coercing them into behaviour that then ultimately, they can use for their own gratification.
So, from my standpoint of previously working with sex offenders and working with individuals that have more of those antisocial personality characteristics or psychopathic characteristics that could be present for someone, there’s more similarities in that. And really, it’s not necessarily any type of new phase. It’s just really a new platform.
SG: So, one aspect that we’ve been talking about over the last couple of years, Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE), how do you understand Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE)? And what does that term help practitioners recognise that older categories missed? And then connected to that, where might it obscure meaningful differences between ideological commitment, sadistic gratification, a desire for notoriety and a hatred of society?
KG: So, I think that Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE) really represents another evolution of the threat for us as law enforcement officers and having to really be proactive in understanding it. And I feel like that terminology, Nihilistic Violent Extremism(NVE), comes from a place of really trying to assist and be helpful with us to know what we’re dealing with. And so, if we put it into a category that we understand, we’re able to have tools to deal with that, you have a time and behaviour that is happening that no one has seen before.
And it is absolutely chilling. And it is absolutely moving faster than any of us ever anticipated or thought could happen. And so, there is a need to define, there is a need to understand so that then we know how to get in front of it or how to address it. So, I feel like the Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE) does that, right? It focuses on that nihilistic view, right? That life has no meaning, no purpose. It is utilising violence as a way to perpetuate that. If life has no meaning and no purpose, then what does it matter what we do? And ultimately, the extremism part comes from really wanting to have that destruction of civilisation and really sow chaos and take over in a way that’s not helpful.
I think what happens though, is normally when you are dealing with some type of extremism, there’s an ideology that’s a part of it. And Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE)is kind of framed under that ideology umbrella. But when you get at the heart of it, there’s a lot more that’s different about it. And so, it’s kind of like when you have a situation that changes, right? So, if we look at the virus that mutates, it’s constantly changing. It has some parts of what was once known, it mutates into something else. I’ve always thought about this as when I’ve looked at it, and like I said, I understood why Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE) was put together in that way, but it never really fit very well. There was a lot more different about it than what brought it together.
And so, from my standpoint, I always felt like what was very clear was the predatory behaviour, the sadistic exploitation of others. And for me, it felt more in line with some of the traditional violent sex offending behaviour that I had seen previously with my work as a clinical and forensic psychologist. And so again, it doesn’t nicely fit anywhere.
And that’s what happens when threats evolve. We can’t always put them in the same bucket. And so, I think the risk is if we try to put it into that extremism bucket, people are going to lock in on an ideological component, and they’re going to miss really what’s underneath it. And underneath it, you have that real sadistic online exploitation that’s happening. You have an offender who is perpetrating harm to others for their own gratification. You have a performative violence that comes from it where they ultimately need to catalogue that violence and show it in some way to have bona fides in that group or to have status in that group.
And so, it’s really a perfect storm of where you have a lot of individuals that are vulnerable online, and you have people out there that are looking for those vulnerable victims and are able to perpetrate that crime. And so, I feel ultimately, we have to look at the behaviour. We need to stop putting so much time into defining it potentially, right, or putting it into certain categories, because it changes so fast. So, by the time we actually demonstrate some type of clear guidance or aspect related to this threat, it’s changed, and it’s no longer relevant in that way.
And so really focusing on that behaviour, and if you have somebody that you’re looking at with these cases, and you see obviously this outrageous behaviour that is absolutely harmful and sadistic and just probably the worst stuff you’ve ever seen, just incredibly cruel, we have to then ask, what are they getting out of that? And that helps us understand what we’re dealing with and helps define that behaviour.
And if we respond and address the behaviour, I think we’ll get in front of the threat a little bit faster than versus trying to put it into some type of specific category or a specific area that we already have tools set up to deal with it, because again, it doesn’t quite fit. And so, we can put it there, and we can try, and we’ll have some success, but we’ll never really champion over it because we haven’t accurately defined what it is.
SG: It’s very interesting and troubling as to how quickly it is proliferating, as you were discussing. And in networks such as 764 or the Com Network, grooming, coercion, violence, they can become intertwined. How should investigators assess a young person who has been victimised but is also helping to harm others? Because that very much is an example of both the 764 and the Com Network. And what should determine the balance between safeguarding accountability and managing the threat that they pose?
KG: That’s the complexity of this problem that we have right now. And I don’t know that there’s a right answer, but I think though, it’s so important that we recognise that we have to ask those questions, and we have to take an individualised approach. There’s no set guidelines that I can say absolutely 100% this will be how it is. We really have tohave those conversations and understand what do they get out of that behaviour. There’s more to come on these conversations.
Dr. Nathan Brooks from New Zealand and Karen McCaulley who’s an IA (intelligence analyst) with the FBI’s BAU (Behavioural Analysis Unit) and myself have been trying to kind of understand and formulate in a way that makes sense. I think when you have somebody who ultimately was struggling and had their own vulnerabilities that then has taken on more of a predatory mindset or behaviour and has victimised somebody else, rather than put them in that category of an offender, I think we have to ask ourselves, why did that happen? How did they get there?
And if there is a component where the individual you can see in their discussions was surviving in that moment, meaning that if they did not do what was required of them, they were going to suffer more harm, or somebody in their life close to them that they loved is going to suffer more harm, or they were going to have to do something egregious like kill their pet or hurt their sibling. And so ultimately, they took a different route that still caused harm but ultimately allowed them to survive in that coercive dynamic of that manipulation that had occurred online.
That is a different person than somebody who enjoyed that harm that they caused, was somebody who found power and energy in that in a way they never had and ultimately thrived in that environment of causing that harm. When we have somebody who thrives in that environment of exploiting others online, or causing violence to occur, or ultimately has that power and control that is intoxicating to them, I would wonder more about psychopathic characteristics in their personality, anti-social traits in their personality. And that’s what we need to find. We need to figure out who are those psychopaths in the group who ultimately are not able to get better, who will constantly seek out to exploit others for their own needs, who find enjoyment in other people’s pain.
Those individuals have to be handled through the criminal justice system, and there’s not much I can do as a psychologist to make that better. I can put boundaries on them, I can attempt to understand how dangerous they are through their behaviours and their narrative that they’re willing to share, but ultimately, they will be a challenge.
Versus if I have somebody who comes from a legitimate history of abuse, trauma, pain, agony, they don’t feel like they’re worth anything, they have been victimised over and over again. This is just another victimisation in that long-standing pattern of victimisation they’ve been exposed to, and in order for them to survive, they had to hurt somebody. That person can be helped. That person is broken but can be fixed through ongoing mental health care and treatment.
But if we go at those two individuals that have those backgrounds that are so different the same way, we lose the ability to rehabilitate who we can, and we put everybody into this category that I don’t know is helpful. And so, if we want to get in front of this, we have to understand that there are those individual drivers to that behaviour, that sometimes people participate in the behaviour for reasons we can’t understand. But if we ask them and walk through it and present ourselves in a genuine way, with empathy, to allow them to feel safe to share, we may then be able to decipher who we have in front of us. Do we have that person who needs additional help, who’s broken, or do we have somebody who really, we can’t help at this stage?
SG: Yes, it’s complex. And tied to that across your casework, what significance has misogyny had in terms of this, coercive control, sexual entitlement, they’ve all had in terms of understanding an offender’s trajectory? Do investigators sometimes miss opportunities to recognise a wider security threat because abuse of women is treated as a separate, private matter, as a social issue? As you know, it’s something I’ve myself been researching a lot on, but I’d be very interested in your take.
KG: Yeah, I think that misogyny is an important element that all of us should be aware of and look for. The unfortunate part is I feel like misogyny is woven into the fabric of our lives no matter where you are, and so it gets missed and people don’t understand that dynamic. And when you start to actually ask yourself, what is misogynistic about this, or are there elements of misogyny present, I think then it really opens the door to understanding those dynamics.
I think that it’s easy to separate different crimes that have been committed. And so, you have potentially women who suffer under a domestic violence situation, intimate partner violence situation, that get put over in one category. You have terrorists that get put over in another category. You have other sex offenders put in another category. I understand why we do that as law enforcement because it’s how we really divide our resources and tools to stay ahead of those different criminal violations that happen. But violence is violence, and being able to look at those elements, there’s a lot of times more connectivity to it than we think. And when we put them in those different categories or buckets, we run the risk of having silos, right? And not being as well informed.
So, I think for all of us, we have to recognise the significant role of misogyny and ask when we see it. Ultimately, it justifies bad behaviour. And so, when we are looking at the offender or the victim of the situations that we are looking at, asking different questions, I think, is important like that, because we routinely get into our regular order of questions that are going to help establish a crime has been committed and help further that prosecution. I understand that. I’m not saying don’t do that. I’m just asking to add to it, a little bit, different layers and really trying to understand those drivers to that behaviour. Because ultimately, then you will be able to see there’s more connection to that and understand it in a way that could be helpful in either further conversations or further restrictions that need to be placed on that person related to any type of arrest scenario that they might be facing.
SG: Yes, I think the way you’ve unpacked it just demonstrates the significance of it, but also the amount of work that’s still required as we move ahead. You previously had described a case in which a sheriff, a family, and a school helped a young man move away from a fixation on school shooters. What made that intervention work and how do you assess whether risk has genuinely reduced, rather than the person simply becoming less visible to authorities?
KG: It’s a great case to be able to talk about and share and I think it really illustrates a few key components. One, that case comes into the law enforcement channels through an individual who’s struggling with suicidality. We know now more than ever more about the risk that we face in our communities related to targeted violence and how offenders go on to commit that behaviour. We know that suicidality can sometimes be that link to homicidality. In this case, it’s a perfect case of where the intervention happened sooner and allowed growth and stability to happen that prevented any type of progression to any type of violence.
I feel like the suicidality that we see and that we hear about has become normalised and almost becomes just, it is what it is. And I feel like when we start to say things like that, or we start to see it that way, we really are basically condoning some type of bad outcome, or really kind of giving up and saying there’s nothing I can do about it. And the exact opposite is really true. If someone is struggling with life circumstances and their response, is I want to die, that’s a problem and we need to address that.
So, in this case, that’s exactly what happened. A sheriff had received training related to key things to look for, again, in this pursuit of preventing violence. And suicidality is one of those, right? Again, suicide is self-murder. It is a harmful act. It needs to be addressed proactively just like anything. And if we address suicidality proactively, then we know it won’t progress to homicidality. And so, we’re trying to get ahead of it sooner versus later. And in this case, that’s what happened. This sheriff recognised the significance of that suicidal behaviour and used it as an opportunity to get in front of it in a very caring and human way.
I feel what made the difference in this case is that that sheriff showed up and showed that young man that he mattered, and that he had worth, and that the sheriff cared about him. And in that scenario, that young man had never felt that, had always felt ashamed and struggled and had his own personal life circumstances that were challenging. And he was trying to do the best he could with the resources he had. And he had challenges in that area.
And so, the sheriff showed up not only with a real human approach and a genuine care and concern for this person, but also with a whole bunch of tools that this person didn’t have, and allowed that connection to be fortified between them, and allowed all these resources to come to the table that now that young man wasn’t alone. He wasn’t left with just his dark thoughts. He wasn’t left with just suicide as a tool. He was left with options. And that was an incredibly rewarding and empowering experience for him to feel that.
Once somebody feels that they’re worthy and they have purpose and that they’re cared for, their options open up. The concern for us, for individuals that contemplate true mass violence, is that that narrows, and pretty soon they start to feel their only purpose is through their death, or their only purpose is through that violent act. And ultimately, they seek to be known, right? Seek to have that notoriety, seek to be a somebody versus a nobody, seek to make people pay for what’s happened to them. So, if we know that that’s some of the motivational drivers to mass violence in this scenario, again, we’re getting in front of it very fast.
And I don’t know that this young man would have gone on to commit any type of violent act other than his suicidal struggles, but it’s the perfect case of where interventions happened early, they happened fast, they happened in a genuine way, where this sheriff approached this young man as a person in pain versus a threat or a cause or a situation, and really worked with him to get him to higher ground.
And that was life changing. That young man has never forgotten that. That sheriff has probably never forgotten it either, because it was taking some very simple concepts. It didn’t cost any money; it didn’t cost a whole bunch of men and women in the law enforcement community to rally together. It really came down to the sheriff, came down to the young man, his family, and the school. And they all worked together to address those needs for him that he was struggling with and give him those options. And so, it is a good news story. It is a great example of what we can do when we come together and we just really approach someone as a human being, and that we’re genuine in that pursuit.
And that’s ultimately, I think, what unlocked the doors for this young man, is that when that sheriff came to him and said, ‘listen, I care about you, I want you to be better’. He knew that it was true. He felt it. And in that, the sheriff, again, an important person, coming to his home, taking time out of his day to help him, basically, in that moment, really gave that young man worth that he had never had before. And he felt special. And he felt important. And he understood that now he could do better, because he had people in his corner that could support him.
SG: That is very hopeful. And I think empathy is obviously a key dynamic in that. It’s good that we can have those examples, because otherwise, it can be quite challenging dealing with all of this.
KG: Absolutely. And to the other question you asked about: how do you know someone’s actually getting better versus becoming invisible to law enforcement—they just go away because maybe that problematic behaviour isn’t being reported anymore. I think when we’re looking at individuals that are contemplating some type of violence, and in this case, potentially targeted violence, we know that it takes time to help, especially if we’re dealing with young individuals that are still developing in their brain, they’re still developing in who they are. And so, a lot of times it can take 18 to 24 months of mitigation time related to an adolescent that is struggling. And as part of that, we have to be able to continue to see positive gains.
And as with anything, right, like what does that look like? Sometimes no news is not good news, as we often say. Someone being quiet doesn’t necessarily mean they’re better. And so, we have to look for other variables that show us that they are doing better, that they are thriving. And I think that that’s a key element you want to look for: how are they interacting with their environment? What does their mental wellness look like? And are they thriving in that environment? So how do we do that? We look for those positive gains.
We look for them to have relationships—positive, healthy relationships that they never had before. We look for them to have socially acceptable growth. They have a job that they didn’t have before. They’re doing well in school that they struggled in before. They enrolled in college, and they never had done that before, university, and they have that educational pursuit. They have goals, they have aspirations, and they are working towards that. They have a physical fitness routine that they never had before. Whatever it could be, it’s hobbies and its growth that are not in the pursuit of violence.
So, when we have somebody who is only finding worth and purpose through the predators that they’re meeting online, or through exploiting vulnerable people online, whatever it could be, or in their life that they’re encountering, they only have purpose through that violence, then their options are going to be narrow. And so how can we create purpose in a more socially acceptable way? Many times, in these environments, we just tell them they have to stop that bad behaviour. You have to stop communicating with these people online; you have to stop interacting with this group of friends that is problematic; you just need to stop. And I understand that, because it’s problematic. We also have to replace it with something that is socially acceptable. Otherwise, they’re going to drift right back into that bad behaviour.
And so, giving them some type of purpose that is socially acceptable outside of that is so important, giving them hobbies that are sustainable and help them continue to feel special in a way that we want them to feel special, versus them being in a situation where they feel special because of all the gore that they’ve assembled, or all the sadistic behaviour that they’ve participated in. We want status in more of an appropriate way, with really trying to understand their hobbies and their pursuits. And so, it sounds a little bit cliched when you’re thinking about it, but it is really that simple.
If I have somebody that I’m working with, and we have interventions that happen, I can’t just walk away and be like, ‘Okay, we did an intervention, everything’s good. They’re in mental health treatment now, everything’s good’. I need to continue to stay plugged in to see, are they actively participating in the mental health treatment in an appropriate way? Are they showing those gains in an appropriate way? Am I seeing growth, and continue to stay with that? If I’m looking at somebody, and I see someone who’s not getting worse, but isn’t getting better, then likely there’s probably more problematic behaviour that’s happening that’s being hidden.
And with some of these individuals, the ones that we talked about that thrive on bad behaviour or exploiting others, when that bad behaviour gets exposed, they will go quiet. And they will become more secretive and more covert in their behaviours, and they will hide their intent because they know that they could get in trouble for it. And so,we have to recognise that that is at play. So, if I’m not seeing positive gains, then likely there’s some other factor for why they’re quiet. And I need to be plugged in to try to understand what that could be. And we’re all limited in our resources, and I understand that. This isn’t anything fancy, but it’s again recognising that it takes time to get somebody to higher ground. It takes time to address that bad behaviour. It takes time to really sort out who you’re dealing with. And if somebody is going to be a continued threat or a problem with how they interact with others, you will see that. You’ll see that pattern continue in different ways.
SG: Absolutely. That’s some really important insight that you are providing. So, to wrap up our discussion, drawing on both your FBI experience, but also your Air Force experience, which you also had a career in, what should military leaders learn from behavioural threat assessment about identifying and managing threats within their own organisations? And perhaps if you could change one aspect of how they recognise concerns, share information, or intervene, what would it be, and why?
KG: I think one of the biggest aspects is to recognise that the threat of this type of offender that can go on and commit targeted violence or a terrorism act—there is no specific profile for what that looks like. And we have to recognise that that can happen within our own ranks, that it happens in our own organisations, military environments, outside of the military. And having to be able to really understand that it doesn’t discriminate in that way. Just because someone is connected to our agency, doesn’t mean that they’re not capable of doing something egregious. I feel like a lot of times the question is asked in that way, as far as like, ‘Well, there’s no way that this person could be capable of doing this. They’ve never done this before’. And I feel like that’s short-sighted.
If violence is going to happen, it comes down to the amount of stressors that someone has in their life and the amount of resources they have to deal with it. If you have somebody who struggles day to day—and you might see this in the military—who struggles with day-to-day routine, and then ultimately has real stressors that happen, their choices in that stress state are not going to be ideal and potentially could be isolating into the way of something that’s problematic—formulating grievances, isolating, being suicidal, feeling that they’re being wronged, and really ultimately finding violence as an acceptable solution to a problem. And so if we recognise that it can happen anywhere, and we recognise that there are individuals that are not resilient, that don’t have the ability, the psychological armour to deal with life in a very reasonable way, and recognise we put them into certain stressful situations, and so in some ways we can make their lives more difficult, or we can make them better, through that connection and that social support that we can have.
The number one error, besides someone feeling like it can’t happen here, is when you identify somebody that is struggling in that way, that is making poor decisions, or has potentially come to our attention because of that bad behaviour, the number one response is always to cut your losses with them and be like, okay, your behaviour is incompatible with continued service in the military, or it’s incompatible with continual working in this place, or it’s incompatible with continued placement in this school. And so ultimately, we come across somebody who’s struggling, and ultimately has participated in bad behaviour, and because that bad behaviour is incongruent with our policies and procedures, we ultimately will potentially say in that scenario, they’re no longer a part of this stabilising organisation that they originally were part of. And that happens all the time. I think the problem is that when someone is participating in that bad behaviour, we should be asking the question why, as I’ve stated earlier on, why are they doing this? And sometimes it’s really them telling you, ‘I have a problem, I don’t know how to solve it’.
When you’re dealing with individuals that don’t have the skills in life to make better choices, there is a part of us, no matter what agency you’re attached to, where we own some of that responsibility to teach and help them grow in a positive way. And what I would really like to see happen is when we recognise that bad behaviour, if we could recognise it earlier, if we could start to intervene sooner, then we could help to make it better, versus adding on another rejection, another abandonment, another struggle for that person who we already know is struggling. There have been many cases, especially with the military, where the military is the best thing that ever happened to them, and they had actually excelled in that environment, until stressors happened to them. And again, as life goes, right, not just one stressor happens, you see multiple stressors happening, and for somebody who doesn’t have the skill set, they’re going to be more prone to making a bad choice in that area.
How can we recognise that we have rules and responsibilities we want everyone to adhere to, as well as being helpful in situations and helping restore and build and potentially retain somebody when we recognise those vulnerabilities? I feel like there is growth that’s happening in that area, but unfortunately, sometimes that bad behaviour that comes to light is so significant and egregious, there’s no other choice than that they have to be separated. And that’s where as an organisation, the other thing that we can do is to help educate our individuals in that organisation on what to look for—how to recognise when someone’s struggling early, so we can see them in the beginning when they’re first having those financial difficulties, or they’re having that first poor judgement that we’re able to see, then how can we fold in both that boundary setting that’s needed to help them know that that behaviour is wrong, but then also how to build in some type of rehabilitation so that they can make better choices in the future. And I feel like if we did that in those organisations, especially the military, we would be in a better place.
The reflex always when you’re having a hard, complicated decision in front of you is to get rid of it. And the feeling is that you’ve dealt with it. But all you really have done is push that problem down the road. And you’ve created a lifelong impact on somebody that they’re not going to forget. One of the key things I’ve always asked in looking at somebody who’s struggling and could be contemplating violence is ‘Where did the dominoes start to fall in their life?’ If I go back to where the dominoes started to fall in their life, I can understand where they were, and now where they’re going, and maybe understand that behaviour in a different way. The key factor, though, is I don’t want to be responsible for where the dominoes started to fall. I want to help them continue to build so that dominoes aren’t falling. I want to help them get to higher ground and invest in them. And like we said about that prevention case, I want them to know they matter, and that they have value, and that I’m committed to helping them. If that’s the message, then we are going to have more mitigation than violence.
And so again, that is a key factor. I think that we can continue to grow in that area and really be part of the solution versus…sometimes we make things worse. And I recognise there’s certain times where maybe it’s inevitable. There’s ways that we can go about that that maintains their dignity, remains a respectful interaction with them. And in some ways, if the boundary setting is done in that manner, they can walk away from a very bad situation feeling very cared for. But it has to be delivered in the right way. And that might not be for everybody, right? And so, we have to recognise who on our team could potentially be that key person. But it’s very attainable, and I see this all the time in case support that there’s ways we can make it better. And when we have people locked in to understand that, and how simple it is, that change can be lifelong. And so, we often say in this area, it’s not so much about recognising that behaviour—it’s always important to recognise that behaviour that’s concerning—but what do we do with it? Because ultimately, what we do with it will really impact that long-term change.
SG: Well, that’s a very positive way to end. The change is attainable. And it’s been a very interesting discussion, Kerry, looking at behaviours, profiling that goes into it, understanding the methodology behind it. It’s always fascinating to talk to you. I’m glad we were able to capture all of this into a podcast discussion. So, thank you again, Dr. Karie Gibson, for being on NATO DEEP Dive.
KG: Thank you so much.
SG: Thank you for listening to this episode of NATO DEEP Dive, brought to you by NATO’s Defence Education Enhancement Programme (DEEP). My producers are Marcus Andreopoulos, Victoria Jones, Eve Register, and Henry McCabe. For additional content, including full transcripts of each episode, please visit: deepportal.hq.nato.int/deepdive.
Disclaimer: Please note that the views, information, or opinions expressed in the NATO DEEP Dive series are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily represent those of NATO or DEEP.
This transcript has been edited for clarity.